We are
bombarded in our society by the platitudes of sloganeering:
“Impress for Less,” “Just Do It,” “For Everything Else, There’s
MasterCard.” Everything from airport announcements to street
signs and news bulletins tell us what to do. For 30 years,
Jenny Holzer, who lives in Hoosick Falls, has used the raw
material of language and the tactics of public art to disrupt
the assumptions that clutter the informational landscape.
Projections is a brilliant physical and metaphysical
examination of the totalizing effects of language. It’s the
kind of art we need more of just now, when popular rhetoric
has reached a pitch of inanity.
I have
been to see Projections three times, and each visit
yielded different sensations, always powerfully disquieting.
On my first trip, the museum was crowded with families enjoying
ice cream during a MASS MoCA free day. In the huge darkened
room of Building 5, the site of Projections, children
frolicked while lines of poetry streamed from two enormous
projectors elevated at opposite points in the room. Words
slid and merged along walls, floor, and ceiling. Projections
is one of the best uses of the Building 5 space I have seen;
Holzer’s transitory, shadowy messages foreground the industrial
emptiness. The effect is uncanny and all-encompassing: Although
you can read the poetry line by line, it’s challenging, and
the projectors can seem like searchlights emitting a disorienting,
intermittent glare. Enhancing this effect is the poetry, by
Pulitzer Prize-winning Polish writer Wislawa Szymborska: “The
terrorist has already crossed the street,” viewers read, from
the chilling poem “The Terrorist, He’s Watching.” (The exhibition
promises to run different poems every few months). Block letters
move across visitors’ bodies, literally embodying the power
of language. On my second visit, a quiet weekday, viewers
sat on gigantic grayish-black beanbags specially designed
for the exhibition. Once you sit on one of these preternaturally
cushy bean bags, it’s difficult to get up, furthering the
sense of being at the mercy of ubiquitous, ghostly words.
On my
third visit, it was exhilaratingly haunting to be the only
viewer in Holzer’s den of text. In Holzer’s living language
sculpture, lines of poetry scroll away, like the introductory
text in the movie Star Wars, with the same eerie, epic
timelessness. Sometimes letters become pure shapes. The space
can feel like a cave or like a prison yard, and the poems
echo a drumbeat of fear: “The terrorist has already crossed
the street./The distance keeps him out of danger/and what
a view: just like the movies.” Indeed. The effect of Projections
induces a filmic kind of déja vu because it’s about the inevitability
of narrative structures.
“Tortures,”
one of Szymborska’s poems, speaks to this inevitability, telling
us that throughout human history, “Nothing has changed . .
. The body writhes, jerks and tries to pull away/its legs
give out, it falls, the knees fly up,/it turns blue, swells,
salivates and bleeds.” And in “The Terrorist, He’s Watching,”
a horrifying scene loops back on itself: “The bomb in the
bar will explode at thirteen twenty/Now it’s just thirteen
sixteen./There’s still time for some to go in,/and some to
come out.”
Projections,
Holzer’s first interior projection in the United States, marks
a new phase; previous installations displayed text she authored.
Her fame as a text artist started when, in 1977, Holzer distilled
a Whitney Independent Study reading list into what became
Truisms: one-line generalizations about wealth, gender, and
fear, among other subjects. Holzer printed statements in the
imperative voice such as “Abuse of Power Comes as No Surprise,”
and “A Strong Sense of Duty Imprisons You,” in capital letters
on posters around New York City. Since then, Truisms and other
language works have appeared on T-shirts, human skin, and
digital monitors in contexts ranging from Guggenheim and Venice
Bienniale installations to signs on garbage cans to a projection
on the bank of the Arno River in Florence. Part of Lustmord,
one of her most controversial works, was printed with blood
in a German magazine in 1993 and read, “I Am Awake In the
Place Where Women Die.”
Artists
have experimented with language as a means to destabilize
expectations at least since cubists incorporated words into
paintings. Similar to Holzer, contemporary Barbara Kruger
uses collaged text art to create often political provocations
(such as “Your Body Is a Battleground” on billboards in the
1990s). Holzer, however, is more interested in existential
questions that cut right into the lexical heart, exploring
boundaries between reality and language, bodily self and world.
How to live with a body in a world that won’t acknowledge
pain? How do we speak to one another when every word has the
potential to lock the door to understanding?
Don’t
miss her series of silkscreen paintings upstairs: They are
declassified government documents—maps and e-mails—about the
Iraq war copied in gray, flat tones. The documents are shocking,
emphasizing the nonsensical imperatives of war: “seize,” “exploit,”
and “execute” appear over and over. When actions in the political
arena arise from such violent words, one has to question the
very nature of language. There’s no one better suited to the
task than Holzer in this stunning exhibition.