Proctors,
Through Nov. 28
Irving
Berlin’s White Christmas, now settled in for a pre- and
post-Thanksgiving stay on the mainstage at Proctors, is as
colorful and dazzling as the best Christmas toy you ever saw
in a department store as a child. By which I mean an old-timey,
made-in-America toy, not a computer-chip controlled electronic
device made by an evil multinational corporation. Set in the
20th-century show business world composer Irving Berlin played
such a large role in creating, White Christmas is a
classic boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl story,
with wall to wall singing and plenty of room for dancing.
While
everyone in the show, including the chorus, dance and sing,
John Scherer (as Bing Crosby . . . I mean Bob Wallace) and
Amy Bodnar (as Rosemary Clooney . . . I mean Betty Haynes)
do more singing, and Denis Lambert (as Danny Kaye . . . I
mean Phil Davis) and Shannon M. O’Bryan (as Vera Ellen . .
. I mean Judy Haynes) do more dancing. All four are very good,
but it’s O’Bryan who is the real scene-stealer with her vivacious
dancing.
The show
is wonderfully slick, as opposed to just slick. The big dance
numbers, “The Best Things Happen While You’re Dancing” and
“I Love a Piano,” are inspired, with crafty scenery-shifts
and fog effects juicing up the former, and some terrific ensemble
tap work spicing up the latter. The memorable songs, including
“White Christmas” and “Count Your Blessings,” are performed
with heart but not schmaltz.
The show
is based on the 1954 film musical, which was itself a comfy,
audience-friendly exercise in nostalgia (and, as such, the
highest-grossing film of that year). The film’s nostalgia
was specific to the decade following World War II. It was
inextricably tied-in with contemporary memories of the war
and star Bing Crosby’s status as a kind of national institution;
the show doesn’t have that baggage, and the few added-on “greatest
generation”-style references don’t bring anything heavier
than a warm, vaguely patriotic glow to the proceedings.
The movie
was also given edge by Berlin’s anxieties about the sea-change
in what constituted post-war entertainment. His discomfort
came through strongly in “Mandy,” a cranky minstrel-show number
sans blackface, and “Choreography,” which sourly lampooned
modern dance; both of those songs have been jettisoned, replaced
by more famous—and much better—tunes from Berlin’s vast songbook.
This
is the where the show outpaces the film: the battle Berlin
feared with newfangled kinds of show biz is long over, and
audiences can be nostalgic for—and happily venerate—the craft
and inspiration Berlin brought to even seemingly throw-away
tunes like “Snow.” (There is no throwaway tune in the show,
except for the plot-advancing “What Can You Do With a General?”)
The added-on songs include the haunting “How Deep Is the Ocean”
and “Let Me Sing and I’m Happy.” The former deepens the romance
in the last act; the latter is a showstopper for Ruth Williamson
as the brassy Broadway gal-turned-switchboard operator,
The show
improves on the film in one more aspect: the book. The film’s
plot contrivances are replaced with other, less gimmicky plot
contrivances. Believe me, that’s not feigned praise.