|
From
China With Hope
By
Kathryn Lurie
Photos
by Joe Putrock
More
and more adoptive parents look to China and its large number
of abandoned girls
‘People
say to me, ‘Why China? Why not Guatemala? Why not Russia,
or why not domestically?’” says Christine Rant of Albany.
“And I say, ‘Because she’s not in Guatemala, she’s in China.
. . . I just got this sense that the child who was waiting
for me was in China.”
Rant and
her husband Doug Ebersman adopted their daughter, Nora ZiQing
Ebersman, in Nanchang, China, in January. “It sounds a little
new age or out there or whatever, but I’ve always had the
sense that that’s where she was going to be and I really couldn’t
say why.”
Understandably,
adoption is an extremely personal decision that a family makes
for a variety of reasons. In addition to a sense of what feels
right, people turn to China for reasons that include the dependability
of the Chinese adoption program, the relatively low expenses,
and the high availability of Chinese children for adoption.
When
Rant and Ebersman were ready to start their family, they found
themselves in a situation where “having biological children
was going to be more difficult and involve more high-tech
stuff than we were ready to do,” says Rant. They started considering
other options, and they came to the decision that adoption
was a fantastic alternative for them. Rant explains, “It’s
the same reason people say, ‘I just want to have biological
children, because I feel like it’s something I need to do.’
I think that’s what happens to adoptive parents to a certain
extent.”
 |
| Doug
Ebersman and Christine Rant with their daughter, Nora
ZiQing Ebersman. |
“Especially
considering . . . we started looking around and we started
realizing all these kids who needed homes,” Ebersman adds.
“So it was a combination of things.”
Johna
Herbinger and her husband Todd of Clifton Park had the same
type of experience. They adopted their little girl, May Louise
Herbinger, in Guangzhou, China, in August.
“We tried
[to conceive],” said Herbinger, “but I didn’t believe in all
the drugs and stuff. . . . I always wanted to adopt from China.
Through my whole life, every once in a while I’d say, ‘I’d
like to adopt a Chinese baby.’ I don’t know why.”
Since
China opened its doors to international adoption in 1992,
the trend of Americans adopting orphaned little girls from
that country has been steadily growing. According to adoption
statistics from the U.S. Department of State, China leads
the international-adoption pack with 7,044 immigrant visas
issued to orphans coming to the United States in 2004, up
from 6,859 in 2003 and 5,053 in 2002. Russia is the second-most
popular country with 5,865 immigrant visas issued to orphans
coming to the States in 2004.
“The
number of families [adopting Chinese children] has increased
almost exponentially from the early ’90s,” says Dr. Elaine
Schulte, pediatrician and founder of the International Adoption
Program at the Children’s Hospital at Albany Medical Center.
“I see more and more children adopted from China every year.”
The local
Chinese communities are growing in part due to the steady
increase of area families with adopted Chinese daughters.
“I remember
Dianna [McGreevy, of Family Tree Adoption] saying to us that
[Nora] won’t be the only adopted Chinese girl in her school,”
Rant says. “I think that’s a good thing for her in terms of
growing up in this area.”
The Chinese
adoption process generally goes like this: A prospective adoptive
couple meets with an adoption agent like McGreevy. They are
given a bundle of information, including a list of what paperwork
and documents they will need to prepare that will eventually
become their dossier—a thorough collection of information
about the family that will be sent to China. The dossier includes
the family’s home studies, medical records, birth certificates,
financial statements, color photos, marriage certificate,
letter of application, and numerous other documents that will
inform the adoption officials about the family. All of these
documents need to be notarized, certified and authenticated,
which means that each paper needs to have a notary’s stamp,
then county, state department, and Chinese embassy or consulate
stamps attached before the document can be sent to China.
The China
Center of Adoption Affairs then translates the family’s dossier,
and the family is placed on a waiting list for a referral.
Paperwork with a picture of a child the Chinese government
has chosen for the couple gets sent to the adoption agency
when the family is approved to adopt. The adoption agent then
relays the news to the family, and they start planning their
trip to China to meet their daughter.
Getting
the dossier together can be a daunting chore. “It takes most
families about three to four months to become paper-ready,”
McGreevy says.
“I started
[working on the dossier] in July 2004,” Herbinger said. “I
went and picked up the list, and slowly, I just started doing
things. I looked at it and I was like, ‘Oh, I have a copy
of our marriage certificate’ . . . So I did that, and writing
the letter asking to adopt wasn’t hard either. So one by one,
I picked things off. But I didn’t rush to get things done.”
Ebersman
didn’t think that the application process was “that bad.”
He says that he thinks it’s a positive thing that the preparation
takes so long; it makes you want to do it only if you’re really
serious about adoption. “I think there’s a method to the madness,”
he says. “How long it takes to do this is probably how long
most people need to understand the process. And you need time
to get ready. Once you even make the decision that this is
what you want to do, you still need some time to process the
whole thing and think about what’s going to work and get the
baby’s room together, and learn how to take care of a child.”
But, he adds with a grin, “You only learn when you’re panicking,
because you don’t know what to do.”
Schulte,
who has two adopted Chinese daughters ages 8 and 9, specializes
in the medical care of internationally adopted children. “I
get involved with the families usually when they get their
[adoption] referral,” she says. “They call me and they want
me to help interpret it, look at the child, look at the picture,
look at the growth parameters, interpret any laboratory data
that’s available. I do that kind of preparatory guidance.”
The Chinese
adoption program has become very appealing for many prospective
adoptive families because it has been in place for a long
time and it’s been a very dependable process.
“At this
point, it’s a very well-greased track,” Rant says. “It’s been
very reliable in terms of people who want to build their families
through adoption. It’s straightforward. . . . You go there
for 10 days, you do this, this and this, everything was laid
out exactly how they said it was going to be, there’s no extra
wait time or extra money.”
“When
you look at the Chinese program, [there are] these girls who
definitely need homes,” Ebersman adds, “and you know that
there’s a limited period of time and you know that at the
end of it, you will have a child. If you go through the process
right, that is very appealing when you consider what the alternatives
are. In China, these girls have no homes. There’s no one claiming
them. There’s nowhere they can go.”
People
have brought up—and probably will in response to this article—the
point that there are thousands of children right here in the
United States who are waiting to be placed. Just as a family’s
decision to adopt is a personal one, so is the decision to
adopt internationally. While there are many negative myths
surrounding domestic adoption, it is not inaccurate to say
that the process has proven to be an arduous one for many
families who choose to go that route, especially for couples
looking to adopt infants.
“There
are two types of domestic adoptions,” McGreevy says. “What
might be considered a young-child or infant adoption is [one]
type. Some people choose to go that route because they do
have the opportunity to adopt a newborn. They may potentially
even be in the delivery room if the birth family is open to
the adoptive couple being there.”
However,
as McGreevy points out, this type of adoption involves a lot
of uncertainty and poses many questions, like: How long is
the wait? What do I have to do so that someone will select
me? In terms of paperwork, domestic adoptions are no less
laborious than international, with one obvious exception—the
adoptive family doesn’t have to fill out immigration forms.
“Once
they are paper-ready and approved,” says McGreevy, “prospective
adoptive parents have to start advertising [so that] a woman
who may have an unplanned pregnancy, who’s considering
placing her child for adoption, [can] find out about them.
So for some families, they know there are so many people who
are out there trying to do this . . . they think it’s a needle
in a haystack.”
 |
| Todd
and Johna Herbinger with their daughter, May Louise Herbinger. |
A common
myth about domestic adoption is that it’s much cheaper than
adopting internationally. “That’s a big misconception,” says
McGreevy. “Domestic adoption is no less expensive.” A domestic
infant adoption can cost anywhere from $15,000 to $40,000,
while a Chinese adoption typically costs about $18,000 (making
China the cheapest country to adopt from). “As far as domestic
infant adoption, you’re spending money on advertising, agencies,”
McGreevy says, “You have to put ads in the newspapers and
the yellow pages just to let a pregnant woman know that this
is a place where she could go.”
Prospective
adoptive parents who want to adopt a domestic infant usually
will spend a significant amount of money on Web sites, networking,
and eventually, most likely, expenses for the birth mother
once they find a woman who’s pregnant, in case she doesn’t
have health insurance or needs help with living expenses.
But the enormous risk with this process is that just because
the couple pay the woman money, she is in no way legally obligated
to give up her baby. “You’re never guaranteed that that adoption’s
going to happen, because you’re not buying a baby,” McGreevy
says. “You’re paying for services.”
An unsettling
risk that parents have to consider when adopting in this manner
is that a mother who places her newborn for adoption has a
period of time in which she’s legally allowed to change her
mind about her decision. In New York state, a birth mother
commonly signs an out-of-court consent, giving her 30 days
to reconsider.
“Of course,
[that’s] the big one everyone talks about—and it does happen,”
McGreevy says. “But it’s based on the best interests of the
child. Not the adoptive parents, but the child. And that’s
a huge risk for some families, [and] they don’t know if they
can handle it.”
This
possibility is very frightening for couples who are looking
to adopt. Horror stories do exist in the adoptive community
about situations in which the mother changes her mind about
giving up her child.
“We met
a couple who adopted from China,” says Rant, “[but] they had
planned to adopt domestically, and they had waited years and
had a whole thing set up with a birth mother, and set up the
baby’s room and the baby was coming, and then the birth mother
left. She took off, and they were devastated, and they walked
away and said, ‘That’s it.’ ”
“Once
you decide you want to start a family,” adds Ebersman, “and
you’re trying to figure out how you’re going to do that in
the best way, you start to realize that you don’t necessarily
want to wait another three or four years to try to get there.
You want to have a process in place that’s going to bring
you to a child that you can give a home to.”
The second
type of domestic adoption is usually done through the Department
of Social Services, involving children who have been in foster
care. This type of adoption is not nearly as expensive—in
fact parents who take foster-care placements are paid by the
county until adoption. Parents trying to get young children
through temporary placements that may become permanent have
even more uncertainty than in traditional adoptions, however—for
up to a year and a half—about whether they will end up keeping
the child. “In foster care, the goal is to reunite that child
with their family,” notes McGreevy.
There
are kids available through foster care who are completely
freed for adoption; however, these are usually much older
children. Many couples who are adopting for the first time
do not feel equipped to handle a preadolescent child.
“You
can adopt an older child,” Ebersman says, “but as a first-time
parent you might not be comfortable doing that.”
“Your
parents wanted so much to care for you and try to give
birth to a son,” explains a children’s book on Chinese adoption.
When You Were Born in China by Sara Dorow kindly but
frankly addresses the political atmosphere and gender preferences
in China and the reasons why the little girl who may be reading
the book was adopted.
As McGreevy
points out, there are political and social reasons why all
of these children are available for adoption. “Children become
available in different countries for different reasons, she
says. “In China, the big known one is the one-child policy,
although that has laxed over many years. Poverty is another
big one.”
Since
Chinese parents traditionally prefer boys for various reasons
(they are the children who typically take care of their elderly
parents, and they are also the ones who can carry on family
names), one common result of China’s famous one-child policy
is that parents often abandon their daughters in hopes of
bearing sons.
“It’s
a really tragic situation with China,” Ebersman says. “You
know that the kids really have no place to go. It’s illegal
for them to be abandoned in the first place, and there’s nobody
to take them. The plight of these poor girls. . . . You adopt
one girl and you just hope that the rest can survive.”
Nora was
found on the steps of a government building in her hometown
of Feng Cheng City with a note in her clothing saying that
she had been born that day. “All I can say is she is an amazing
girl,” Ebersman says of his daughter. “We are very fortunate,
and truth is, she’s very fortunate too, to not be there.”
Similarly,
May was left on the steps of an orphanage in the middle of
the night when she was 2 weeks old. An employee at the orphanage
found her in the morning. Herbinger was the only parent in
her group of adoptive parents to receive a letter with her
baby. “I’m lucky,” she says, “because I have a lot of information
about why they left her—her parents left a note. They said
that they were just very poor and they could not afford to
feed her. The area in China where she came from is a very
poor area, very rural. They apologized and said, ‘Please find
a good family for her.’ ”
In the
United States, when you hear about abandoned children, it’s
usually not done with the expectation that something good
will come of it, says McGreevy, referring to what have become
known as “dumpster babies.” In China, however, girls are abandoned
with the hope that they will be found. “In China, the babies
are left in very crowded places, and that’s partly how they’re
able to do it and slip into the crowd. We want parents to
know, imagine how incredibly painful that has to be, and the
huge leap of faith [the birth parents take] that their baby’s
going to be found and taken care of.”
According
to McGreevy, China’s adoption program has continued to improve
over the years, resulting in the country becoming a leader
in foreign adoption programs. “They have all kinds of foundations
in their country,” she says. “They now provide developmental
check sheets [with the referrals]; they know that families
want to know, ‘What developmental milestones [is] my child
reaching?’ So that’s another reason why the China program
in general has become so popular. They continue to improve
on it. They are using the money [from adoptions] and they
are improving the system as a whole.”
 |
| Helping
families through the process: Dianna McGreevy of Family
Tree Adoption. |
A big
part of the adop- tion process is the two-week trip to China
that the family must take to receive their child. There, the
family completes the adoption process and signs all the necessary
paperwork to bring their daughter home. They also experience
a bit of Chinese culture and gain some perspective about the
country.
Traveling
to the country where the family is adopting from “is a huge
benefit for the family,” says McGreevy. “It [provides] a whole
piece about why she’s joining your family [and] you can begin
to understand how all this is possible.”
“You
can’t believe the scale of it till you’re there and you see
how many kids there are,” says Ebersman, “and these are just
the ones who are getting homes.”
Herbinger
met her daughter at the civil affairs office in Guangzhou.
“When we got there,” she says, “the day we were to get her,
I was a nervous wreck. It’s just like, your whole life is
going to change.”
“They
had them all lined up and they had them all in identical outfits,”
says Rant of her experience meeting her daughter at the civil
affairs office in Nanchang. “All we had were these referral
pictures that had been taken, and they said to us ‘Guess which
baby is yours.’ It was just so surreal. They started to read
the names off, but we knew who it was.”
“If we
could say one thing to sum up our experience,” Ebersman says,
“It’s that, ‘It’s OK for people to adopt children.’ We didn’t
come from families where anyone had ever adopted. We didn’t
even know that that was an alternative that we could do, that
our families would be OK with. It’s a whole new world for
us. We love our daughter. We wouldn’t want it any other way.
But we didn’t know that that was an option for us.”
“It’s
an amazing thing, too,” Rant says. “When you go there and
get this child, every single person walks away and says, ‘This
child is familiar to me. I know her. She seems to be the right
child for me. Somebody just knew to give me this baby, and
she’s my daughter.’ I don’t know. . . . It’s right. It’s just
right.”
klurie@metroland.net
Adoption
Resources
There
are countless Web sites and agencies that exist to aid in
the process of adopting a child from China, as well as there
are support groups, community centers and counselors who provide
support post-adoption. Here are just a few of these resources,
some of which were used for this story.
Local
Resources
Family
Tree Adoption
Dianna
McGreevy, program director-founder
(800)
272-3678 or 371-1336, www.familytreeadoption.org
2 Crestmont
Drive, Route 146, Clifton Park
International
Adoption Program at the Children’s Hospital at Albany Medical
Center
Department
of Pediatrics
AMC Pediatric
Group
1 Clara
Barton Drive MC-181, Albany
Elaine
Schulte, MD, MPH, medical director-founder
262-6086,
www.amc.edu
Families
With Children From Asia (Albany chapter)
www.fca-ny.org
Chinese
Community Center, Capital District of New York
www.cccalbany.org
Adoptive
Families Coalition
www.timesunion.com/communities/
afc
National
Resources
U. S.
Department of State, Bureau of Consular Affairs
http://travel.state.gov
China
Center of Adoption Affairs
www.china-ccaa.org
Families
With Children From China
www.fwcc.org
Rainbow
Kids
www.rainbowkids.com
United
States Department of Health and Human Services: Administration
for Children and Families
www.acf.hhs.gov
 |
|